Tick-Range Mechanism

Sorting And Tracking Liquidity Distribution

Introduction

In order to enable LPs to specify liquidity positions with customized price intervals, the protocol needed a way to track the aggregated liquidity across various price points. Uniswap V3 achieved this feat by partitioning the space of possible prices into discrete "ticks" whereby LPs could contribute liquidity between any two ticks.

Whenever you add/remove liquidity to a tick range (including a lowerTick and upperTick), the pool has to record how much virtual liquidity is kicked in/out when crossing these ticks and how many tokens are used to activate the liquidity within the range.

Critically, by defining ticks in relation to the price, it enables neighbouring ticks to scale according to the absolute price (i.e. each tick will always be a fixed % price movement from their neighbouring tick). As a result of this design, LPs are able to add liquidity within the closest tick ranges that approximates their preferred liquidity provision price range.

Implementation overview

The series of diagrams below illustrates the tick-range mechanism for your convenience.

1. Price space is divided into discrete ticks (refer Technical explanation below for exact formula)

Discrete ticks

1. LPs add their positions to selected tick ranges as indicated in the table below. Note that the contributed liquidity is evenly spread across all the tick intervals within the selected tick range.

Position	Total Value	Tick Range	Tick Intervals	TVL Per Tick Interval
1	500	$T_1 - T_6$	5	100
2	1200	$T_4 - T_8$	4	300
3	500	$T_5 - T_{10}$	5	100

3 separate liquidity positions

1. From the protocol's perspective, it is now able to track the total liquidity per tick interval as well as the proportional split between all positions within that interval.

Tick Interval	TVL	P1 Proportion	P2 Proportion	P3 Proportion
$T_1 - T_2$	100	100 (100%)	-	-
$T_2 - T_3$	100	100 (100%)	-	-
$T_3 - T_4$	100	100 (100%)	-	-
$T_4 - T_5$	400	100 (25%)	300 (75%)	-
$T_5 - T_6$	500	100 (20%)	300 (60%)	100 (20%)
$T_6 - T_7$	400	-	300 (75%)	100 (25%)
$T_7 - T_8$	400	-	300 (75%)	100 (25%)
$T_8 - T_9$	100	-	-	100 (100%)
$T_9 - T_{10}$	100	-	-	100 (100%)

Tick TVL with each position shown

As long as the market continues to trade within a particular tick interval, the fees will be distributed to the LP according to the proportion of liquidity that the LP added to the active tick. As the market moves towards either extremes of the tick interval, the corresponding liquidity in the pool will be gradually depleted until only a single token is left in that interval. Upon crossing a tick, the protocol then activates the liquidity within the next interval and the process is repeated according to the direction of price movement.

The amplitude of the tick range can be controlled by the protocol by specifying a tick spacing which determines the potential active ticks. Based on the price correlation between assets in the pool, capital can be more efficiently utilized by setting a smaller tick interval (as more liquidity is concentrated into a smaller interval to support trades). The flipside of this is that additional gas is consumed whenever a tick is crossed as the liquidity within the activated tick has to be activated. Due to these factors, pools with various fee tiers have been created to cater to the different liquidity preferences of LPs.

Technical explanation

A tick is approximated as the square root price that is an integer power of $\sqrt{1.0001}$:

$\sqrt{p(i)} = 1.0001^i$

Through the above equation, it allowed each tick to be defined as a ~0.5 basis point price movement from its neighbouring ticks. By specifying the tick spacing, the protocol can then determine the potential active ticks for each pool. For example, a tick spacing of 2 would result in each neighbouring tick being within ~1 basis point of the active tick.

Ticks concentrated liquidity - LinkedList​

KyberSwap implements this tick range mechanism via a linked list data structure. As mentioned above, we need to store information about each tick to track the amount of net liquidity that should be added and removed when the tick is crossed. As a result, the tick's variables must contain the net liquidity of liquidity providers and the fee outside of the tick.

All these information is stored in the TickData struct

struct TickData
    uint128 liquidityGross;
    int128 liquidityNet;
    uint256 feeGrowthOutside;
    uint128 secondsPerLiquidityOutside;
 

Indeed, when swapping, the total amount of liquidity that is added or removed when the tick is crossed goes left and right. So we need to track the liquidityNet, which is the total amount of liquidity that is added and removed when the tick is crossed. This value is one signed integer: the amount of liquidity added when price moves rightward, and if we're moving leftward, we interpret liquidityNet as the opposite sign.

Between several ticks, there remains a possibility that we will not have any liquidity. As a result, to optimize, we only initialize a tick if and only if it has liquidity referencing the tick. The liquidityGross ensures that if net liquidity at a tick is 0, we can still know if a tick is referenced by at least one underlying position, which tells us whenever to initialize the tick.

We use feeGrowthOutside to track how much fees were accumulated within a given range. feeGrowthOutside needs to be updated each time the tick is crossed.

There could be several ticks that are not initialized and we only access/process data of initalized ticks, we need a data structure to store all initialized ticks with the ability to move from one initialized tick to its 2 adjacent initialized ticks optimally. To do so, we use a doubly linked list to store all initialized ticks.

The doubly linked list of initialized ticks is stored in the initializedTicks from the PoolStorage, each Linkedlist data consists of 2 variables:

struct Data
    int24 previous; // the previous data in the doubly linked list
    int24 next;     // the next data in the doubly linked list

Field	Type	Explanation
previous	int24	the previous data in the doubly linked list
next	int24	the next data in the doubly linked list

Initiallly, its HEAD is MIN_TICK and its TAIL is MAX_TICK, they will never be removed from the initializedTicks.

Add new tick to the linked list​

When adding a new tick X, users will need to specify the tick Y that is initialized. To save on gas, the tick Y will have to be the tick that is closest and lower than the added tick X. However, due to on-chain delay/human error, there are few scenarios that could happen:

• X has been initialized, ignore this case.

• Y has been removed, the transaction will be reverted.

• There are several ticks have been initialized/added between X and Y, to avoid reverting, we allow to jump at most MAX_TICK_TRAVEL from Y to the right to find the nearest initialized tick that is lower than X in the current linked list, i.e: Y < X < Y.next.

Logic

if Y is removed -> revert
While (Y.next <= X && iteration <= MAX_TICK_TRAVEL):
    Y = Y.next
    iteration++;
if Y >= X or Y.next <= X -> revert - invalid lower value

// Add new tick X between Y and Y.next
X.next = Y.next
X.previous = Y
Y.next.previous = X
Y.next = X

Remove a tick from the linked list​

When removing a tick X, there are 3 cases:

• X is MIN_TICK or MAX_TICK, ignore this case.

• X has been removed, the transaction will be reverted.

• Otherwise, remove X by linking its 2 adjacent ticks to each other, and return the previous tick.

Logic:

if X == X.previous -> return X; // X is the lowest tick
if X == X.next -> return X.previous; // X is the highest tick
// Remove tick X by linking its 2 adjacent ticks
X.previous.next = X.next;
X.next.previous = X.previous;
delete X

Range mechanism​

Objective​

The goal is to accurately account a position's accured fees accured and duration for which it is active. A position is defined to be active if the current pool tick lies within the lower and upper ticks of the position.

Global value​

The feeGrowthGlobal and secondsPerLiquidityGlobal variables represent the total amount for 1 unit of unbounded liquidity.

Outside value​

The outside value (feeGrowthOutside and secondsPerLiquidityOutside) for a tick represents the accumulated value relative to the currentTick. By definition, we can visually represent it to be as such:

• tick <= currentTick

  
• tick > currentTick

  

Initialization​

When a tick is initialized, all growth is assumed to happen below it. Hence, the outside value is initialized to the following values under these cases:

• tick <= currentTick: outside value := global value

• tick > currentTick: outside value := 0

Crossing ticks​

Due to the definition of the outside value, a tick's outside value is reversed whenever the pool tick crosses it. Specifically, outside value := global value - outside value.

Note​

When swapping downtick, the current tick is further decremented by 1. This is to ensure a tick's outside value is interpreted correctly. swapData.currentTick = willUpTick ? tempNextTick : tempNextTick - 1;

Calculating value inside ticks​

The current tick can be

1. below a position (currentTick < lowerTick) The value inside can therefore be calculated as tickLower's outside value - tickUpper's outside value

   
2. within a position (lowerTick <= currentTick < upperTick)

   

   The value inside can therefore be calculated as global value - (lower + upper tick's outside values)

3. above a position (upperTick <= currentTick)

   

   The value inside can therefore be calculated as tickUpper's outside value - tickLower's outside value

Tick-range mechanism​

• To represent liquidity mapping, Kyberswap Elastic uses linked list, the linked list always starts by MIN_TICK and ends by MAX_TICK.

• The pool also need to track to the highest initialized tick which is lower than or equal to currentTick (aka nearestCurrentTick).

For example:

• the pool is initialized at tick 5, the linked list will be [MIN_TICK, MAX_TICK] andnearestCurrentTick will be MIN_TICK.

• A adds liquidity at tick [-5, 10], the linked list will be [MIN_TICK, -5, 10, MAX_TICK] and nearestCurrentTick will be -5.

• C adds liquidity at tick [0, 100], the linked list will be [MIN_TICK, -5, 0, 10, 100, MAX_TICK] and nearestCurrentTick will be 0.

• B swaps and currentTick = 15, then nearestCurrentTick will be 10

• A remove all liquidity at tick [-5, 10], the linked list will be [MIN_TICK, 0, 100, MAX_TICK] andnearestCurrentTick will be 0.